Analysis of Admirer 1:
I am unimpressed with this note.
Every rhetorical argument is based on pathos and flattery combined with vague
compliments. The whole thing doesn’t feel genuine. The rare bits of logic are
faulty. First he/she (I cannot be sure, which makes me extremely nervous. I
will refer to the author as a she for the sake of comfort) states “I can’t stop
thinking about you and I can’t keep it in anymore,” and “I want the whole world
to know.” If this desire to reveal to the world her infatuation for me was
genuine, why would she tell me in a secret note? On top of that, why would she
not even tell me her identity? In addition to all of this, if I don’t know who
is speaking or that she likes me, why would she be waiting alone for me “so
many nights”?? I am enormously creeped out by this. Assuming this is genuine, I
am worried for this person’s sanity.
The message is generic, making
me think it was printed out dozens of times, taped to a cheap box of chocolates
and distributed randomly on the doorsteps of people hopefully of the same
gender. I doubt my “secret lover” knows me at all. I can only assume the author of the note is
waiting in an unmarked van with a chloroform soaked handkerchief. In the
hypothetical situation where I receive this gift, I would promptly call
University Police and warn them about suspicious individuals lurking in front
of the complex around midnight.
In summary, I will not be making an appearance at your
romantic meeting. My apologies.
The second admirer seemed nice though. I’d probably
accept her offer.
I agree, this is a very generic love note that could probably be found on a Hallmark card anywhere. I also don't think that it would be safe to go meet this person, based on their note.
ReplyDeleteYour title is awesome. I really like how in all of your posts you use your great sense of humor, and I think that this post is a great use of that humor. I haven't seen it be a problem yet, but make sure you don't get carried away and that you know when to pull the reader in with seriousness. Great job though, I enjoy your posts.
ReplyDeleteLoved your analysis! You had a catchy title too!
ReplyDelete